I know there's no cut and dry way to define "best practices" because every community is different, but here's my scenario:
Our community has 55 blogs
- 51 of them are "product newsrooms" (release information, tips and tricks, roadmap things, etc.)
- 4 of them are more "general purpose" (things happening around the community, marketing messaging, team updates, etc.)
Right now we have specific people set up as authors in their respective places, and that's fine, it works, but....
These 'authors' are not web people - they are technical resources and they don't seem to understand the benefits of post images, tags, titles, headings, links, and all the other things that make the content a) searchable and b) ranked in SEO.
I was toying with the idea of setting up blog approval for some blogs and basically denying their requests if they don't meet our minimum requirements.
I feel like the ideal (in our scenario) would be something like this:
- SEO Review (have it notify the SEO team for a final review)
- Formatting Review (have it meet the community mods' best practices)
- Final Review (have it meet the company's content review guidelines)
My questions are thus:
- If you use approvals, do you have only a single stage, or multi-phase?
- Has this evolved and is it different for different blogs?
- Who (what types of roles) do you have for said phases?
- If you can share a screenshot of your phases, but redacted for privacy, that would be incredibly helpful.
- Do you feel like you needed to include a whole bunch of cross-training for the approvers?
- Many of our potential approvers aren't going to be experts on the community platform, so I worry about them learning (read: "complaining about") one more thing.
- How do you make people accountable for their particular stage?
- Is there an OOTB report?
- Do you just rely on the toaster pops, emails, and other notifications?
I ask because we are a small team responsible for the community (only 4 of us globally) and we can't possibly check up on every blog if we don't know it's happening.