Viewed Content vs. View Count

Something funky is going on with our metrics. In the entire time our community has been live (we're still in pilots), the line chart that shows the total number of views reads 3,601 - which sounds right. Out of curiosity, I wanted to see which pieces of content were getting the most views... and well... it doesn't make any sense.

My top pieces of content have 8,551, 8,466, 8,055, and so on with the unusually high and illogical numbers. In fact, if I export the list and tally up the views, I end up with 355,781 views total. I can very much assure you that is incorrect.

What is going on?